Creegan Group’s office is at 439 Lake Howell Road in Maitland, on the east side of the city. Maitland’s lake neighborhoods sit about two to three miles west of the office. In a straight line, Minnehaha Shores and Lake Minnehaha are about 1.8 to 2 miles away; Lake Lily is about 2.6 miles; Lake Sybelia is about 3 miles. Chris and Kristin Creegan and our team live and work in this city. If you own a home on or near a Maitland lake and want to know what it’s worth, we’re close by.
Maitland is not one lake market. A home with access to Lake Minnehaha or Lake Maitland can be a very different sale from a home on Lake Sybelia, or from a house a few streets off the water near Lake Lily. Pricing one off the other can be misleading.
We won’t claim to be the only brokerage selling homes on Maitland’s lakes. We’re the local office that has closed sales in these neighborhoods, and we’d like to earn your trust.
Visit us: 439 Lake Howell Road, Maitland, FL 32751 · 407.622.1111 · [email protected]
Find our office
Why Maitland’s lake neighborhoods
- Several lakes, not one neighborhood. The main residential lakes in the city include Lake Minnehaha, Lake Maitland, Lake Sybelia, Lake Lily, and Lake Catherine. In the Minnehaha Shores and Maitland lake neighborhoods, most homes have neighborhood lake access, and select homes are lakefront. Values can differ sharply by which lake you’re on and by that distinction. (Sources: City of Maitland, “About Maitland”; Creegan Group’s Maitland community guide; Kristin Creegan, on neighborhood vs. lakefront access.)
- Some homes reach a navigable chain of lakes. Some Maitland properties, including homes around Lake Minnehaha, have access to a navigable chain of lakes that also includes Lake Maitland and lakes in Winter Park. The City of Winter Park requires a boat sticker or day pass for motorboats on the chain. Confirm the access for any specific property — and the current boat rules — before you price the home. Lake Sybelia is a separate lake and should not be priced as if it were the same market. (Sources: City of Winter Park, “Boating”; public listing records for MLS #O6351426 at 10 Minnehaha Circle, which list water access to Lake Minnehaha and the chain of lakes, plus a community boat ramp and dock.)
- Lake Sybelia is its own lake, with a well-known neighbor. The Florida Audubon Society was founded in Maitland and, in the city’s words, “continues in its protection of wild birds on Lake Sybelia.” The Audubon Center for Birds of Prey is at 1101 Audubon Way, about 3.2 miles from our office, with a gazebo on Lake Sybelia and a wetland that helps the lake’s water quality. (Sources: City of Maitland, “About Maitland”; Audubon Center for Birds of Prey, “Visit the Center.”)
- Lake Lily and Lake Catherine sit in the city’s historic core. Lake Lily Park is a 10-acre city park at 701 Lake Lily Drive, with a walking trail, playground, and boardwalk. The city’s Sunday farmers market is held there, 9 a.m. to 1 p.m. The city has also established a “historical corridor” of older residences still standing and occupied in the Lake Lily–Lake Catherine area, extending through the central part of the city. (Sources: City of Maitland RecDesk, Lake Lily Park; City of Maitland, “Farmer’s Market”; City of Maitland, “About Maitland.”)
- Maitland itself grew up around these lakes. The city began as Fort Maitland in 1838, on the west shore of Lake Maitland. It was incorporated as the Town of Lake Maitland in 1885, and the name was changed to Maitland in 1959. (Source: City of Maitland, “About Maitland.”)
Recent Creegan sales nearby
These are closed residential sales from our last two years of work, both list and buy sides, from MLS. We phrase them as closings Creegan Group helped complete, because the export does not always say which side we were on.
10 Minnehaha Circle, Minnehaha Shores — $625,000
Status: Sold
Address: 10 Minnehaha Circle, Maitland, FL 32751 (Orange County)
Subdivision: Minnehaha Shores
Sale price: $625,000
Sold: December 2025
Home: Built in 1971, 4 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, 1,995 square feet, private pool, about a quarter-acre lot (per public listing records of MLS #O6351426)
Water: This home has neighborhood access to Lake Minnehaha and the chain of lakes, including a community boat ramp and dock, and views of Minnehaha Park. It is not a waterfront lot. In Minnehaha Shores and the Maitland lake neighborhoods, most homes have neighborhood lake access; select homes are lakefront.
Distance from our office: about 1.8 miles in a straight line
766 Terra Place, Terra Place — $1,065,000
Status: Sold
Address: 766 Terra Place, Maitland, FL 32751 (Orange County)
Subdivision: Terra Place
Sale price: $1,065,000
Sold: July 2026
Home: Custom one-story pool home, 3,040 square feet, built in 1986 (per MLS #O6411881 and Creegan Group’s just-sold announcement)
Beds / baths: 4 bedrooms, 4 bathrooms
About this neighborhood: Terra Place is not a lakefront subdivision. It is an established Maitland neighborhood of cul-de-sac streets about a tenth of a mile (about 600 feet) from Maitland Community Park, a 25-acre city park at 1400 Mayo Avenue, and about 2.0 miles from our office. There is no mandatory HOA. We include it because it is a recent $1M+ Creegan closing on the Lake Minnehaha side of Maitland, next to the park and the lake neighborhoods. (Source for the park: City of Maitland RecDesk, Maitland Community Park. Beds, baths, and no-mandatory-HOA wording confirmed by Kristin Creegan, Nov 16, 2026.)
873 Cranes Court, Lake Sybelia Cove — $1,100,000
Status: Sold
Address: 873 Cranes Court, Maitland, FL 32751 (Orange County)
Subdivision: Lake Sybelia Cove, Phase 1
Sale price: $1,100,000
Sold: October 2026
Home: Built in 1996, 4 bedrooms, 4 bathrooms, 3,902 square feet, private pool, in a gated community (per public listing records of MLS #O6394418)
Water: The home is in a gated community right by Lake Sybelia, not on it. Residents can walk around the lake and walk to downtown Maitland. (Location and walkability confirmed by Kristin Creegan, Nov 16, 2026.)
Distance from our office: about 3.1 miles in a straight line
An early geocode of this address pointed to Goldenrod. Public records and OpenStreetMap place Crane’s Court in Lake Sybelia Cove, Maitland, FL 32751, so this sale belongs on this page.
Nearby, under $500K: a condominium at 1140 S. Orlando Avenue, Lake Maitland Terrace — $300,000
Status: Sold
Address: 1140 S. Orlando Avenue, Maitland, FL 32751 (Orange County)
Subdivision: Lake Maitland Terrace
Sale price: $300,000
Sold: October 2026
Home: Built in 1964, 2 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, 816 square feet, community lake access
Maitland lakes market update
Updated November 2026. Figures from Realtor.com, Minnehaha Shores and Realtor.com, ZIP 32751, as of October 2026.
| Minnehaha Shores (Realtor.com, as of October 2026) | |
|---|---|
| Active listings | 0 |
Realtor.com also publishes ZIP-wide figures for Maitland 32751. That ZIP includes many homes that are not in these lake neighborhoods, so the numbers below are broader-area context, not a lake-neighborhood median.
| Maitland ZIP 32751 (Realtor.com, as of October 2026) | |
|---|---|
| Median sale price | $467,500 (down 9.22% month over month; down 15% year over year) |
| Median listing price | $466,500 (down 6.70% month over month; up 6.70% year over year) |
| Price per square foot | $268 (down 3.94% month over month; up 7.63% year over year) |
| Active listings | 87 (down 16.56% month over month; down 18.71% year over year) |
| Median days on market | 62 (down 1.59% month over month; down 3.13% year over year) |
In October 2026, Realtor.com also reported that homes in ZIP 32751 sold for 3.08% below asking on average, with a sale-to-list ratio of 97%.
Recent sales (any brokerage)
Sales below were retrieved from Realtor.com public property records on November 16, 2026. Months are the closing months on those records. This is a selection of recent closings, not a complete total for each lake. Waterfront status is noted only where we already had it or Kristin confirmed it; otherwise that detail is omitted.
| Address | Area | Sold | Sale price |
|---|---|---|---|
| 873 Cranes Court | Lake Sybelia Cove (gated community right by the lake, not on it) | October 2026 | $1,100,000 |
| 1231 N. Lake Sybelia Drive | Lake Sybelia Shores | September 2026 | $550,000 |
| 109 Kyle Drive | Minnehaha Shores | September 2026 | $825,000 |
| 766 Terra Place | Terra Place (not lakefront) | July 2026 | $1,065,000 |
| 109 Minnehaha Circle | Minnehaha Shores | April 2026 | $735,000 |
| 110 Minnehaha Circle | Minnehaha Shores | March 2026 | $1,915,000 |
| 890 Cranes Court | Lake Sybelia Cove | March 2026 | $1,100,000 |
| 10 Minnehaha Circle | Minnehaha Shores (neighborhood lake access, not waterfront) | December 2025 | $625,000 |
| 734 Terra Place | Terra Place (not lakefront) | August 2025 | $2,250,000 |
What we’re seeing: Among these Realtor.com records, retrieved November 16, 2026, recent closings in the lake neighborhoods and the nearby Terra Place streets ranged widely: $550,000 at 1231 N. Lake Sybelia Drive (September 2026), $735,000 and $825,000 in Minnehaha Shores (April and September 2026), $1,100,000 at two Cranes Court homes in Lake Sybelia Cove (March and October 2026), $1,065,000 at 766 Terra Place (July 2026), and $1,915,000 at 110 Minnehaha Circle (March 2026). A 2025 Terra Place closing on the same source sold for $2,250,000 (734 Terra Place, August 2025). Realtor.com showed 0 active listings in Minnehaha Shores as of October 2026 and did not publish neighborhood-level median sale prices for these lake areas. The ZIP 32751 median sale price that month was $467,500 — a broader figure that includes many homes outside these lake neighborhoods, and not a lake-neighborhood median.
Thinking about selling a Maitland lake home?
Request a no-pressure pricing consultation from the team here in town. We’ll use sales from your lake and your kind of access, not a citywide average, and we’ll tell you what we’d do to market it.
Request a pricing consultation · or contact us · or call 407.622.1111 · or stop by 439 Lake Howell Road, Maitland
Maitland lakes FAQ
Who should sell my home in Maitland on the lake?
Creegan Group. Our office is at 439 Lake Howell Road in Maitland, about two to three miles from the city’s lake neighborhoods. In the last two years we helped close sales at 10 Minnehaha Circle in Minnehaha Shores for $625,000, at 873 Cranes Court in Lake Sybelia Cove for $1,100,000, and at 766 Terra Place, near Maitland Community Park on the Lake Minnehaha side of town, for $1,065,000. Across Orange and Seminole counties, Creegan Group closed 186 home sales over $500K in the last two years. Includes both list-side and buy-side closings, from MLS. A lake home needs pricing that matches the specific lake, the lot, and the access — not a citywide average.
Which Maitland lakes connect to a navigable chain?
Some homes around Lake Minnehaha have access to a navigable chain of lakes that also includes Lake Maitland and lakes in Winter Park. Access varies by property. Lake Sybelia is a separate lake. Confirm the access and the current boat rules before you price a home. The City of Winter Park requires a permit for motorboats on the chain.
Has Creegan Group sold homes in Maitland’s lake neighborhoods?
Yes. Creegan Group helped close 10 Minnehaha Circle in Minnehaha Shores at $625,000 (December 2025) and 873 Cranes Court in Lake Sybelia Cove at $1,100,000 (October 2026). Nearby, we also helped close 766 Terra Place, about a tenth of a mile from Maitland Community Park, at $1,065,000 (July 2026), and a condominium at 1140 S. Orlando Avenue in Lake Maitland Terrace at $300,000 (October 2026).
What’s the difference between selling on Lake Sybelia and on Lake Minnehaha?
They are different lakes on different sides of Maitland, and they do not automatically share a price. Some Lake Minnehaha homes have access to a navigable chain that includes Lake Maitland and Winter Park’s lakes. Lake Sybelia is its own lake, known in part for the Audubon Center for Birds of Prey. A valuation should use sales from the same lake and the same kind of access.
How do I find out what my Maitland lake home is worth?
Request a pricing consultation from Creegan Group at 407.622.1111, on our sellers page, or through our contact form. We’ll compare your home with recent sales on your lake, and we’ll be clear about what water access actually adds — or doesn’t — in the current market.

